0012. Hash the action graph and the inlined tree separately¶
- Status: Accepted
- Date: 2026-11-12
Context¶
A robot, a review and a log need to name the tree they mean (roadmap FD3).
A file hash does not do it: reformatting a file changes it, and it misses the
subtrees a file includes. Two questions are also different: "is this the same
tree?" and "does this tree behave the same?". A BT.CPP v3 tree and its v4
version, or a tree with an extra Inverter pair, answer them differently.
Decision¶
- Two SHA-256 hashes, written
sha256:<hex>, both computed from the tree and its config alone: - the tree hash, over the canonical XML of the selected tree with every subtree inlined: no whitespace or comments, attributes sorted, port values after remapping, the source format and the tree ID in a header;
- the graph hash, over a canonical JSON of the action graph: actions (id, label, type, ports, notes, subtrees) and edges (source, target, outcome, and each guard term's key and polarity).
- Source locations, file names, diagnostics and node ids are not hashed, so moving a tree to another file or renaming a control node keeps the graph hash.
- Each canonical form carries a version number. Changing a form changes its version and is listed in the changelog.
- The JSON output carries both (
graph_hash,tree_hash), andbeehave graph --print-hashprints them.
Consequences¶
- Equal graphs have equal graph hashes and unequal graphs unequal ones; a property test checks this on random trees.
- The graph hash depends on the walk rules and on
beehave.yaml, so it is compared between results of the same Beehave version and config. The tree hash depends on the tree only. - A tree hash says nothing about behaviour on its own: two trees with different XML can have the same graph.